Helping the poor: do we have a moral obligation to give money to charity?
Peter Singer's ethics suggest that helping the poor is our moral obligation. We focus the normative dimension of the problem of poverty and inequality and discuss if giving money to charity is simply our duty or a sign of generosity. Do you think charity any good?
Helping the poor as a moral obligation
Australian philosopher Peter Singer (see video below) popularized a moral argument about the extensive individual duties of aid to the global poor. For Peter Singer we ought to save the lives even of those we don't know or live very far away as soon as we can do it at very little cost to ourselves. On of the main ethical implications of Singer's reasoning is that giving money to charity is neither generous or charitable, it is simply our duty and not giving would be wrong. Thus, we have a moral obligation to help reduce poverty and prevent hunger, disease and death simply because we can. The failure of people in rich nations to make significant sacrifices to help the poorest, which usually live in developing countries, is ethically indefensible. Being charitable wouldn't make us "good", but failing to be charitable would make us "bad".
Peter Singer's is based on a moral and on an empirical premise:
- Moral: if it is in you power to prevent something bad, without thereby sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, you ought to do it.
- Empirical: if you can save a life by giving a certain amount of money to charity, and giving this amount will not require you to give up anything of comparable moral importance, you ought to do it.
Singer invokes the Pond Case: if you are walking past a pond and see a child drowning in it, you ought to jump in the water and save it, although that would imply ruining your clothes and watch. The cost for you would be insignificat compared to the harm you would prevent.
We can reduce death and suffering by contributing to famine relief and development aid, we ought to do it.
Contrasting views
However, Peter Singer's ethics is not universally accepted. These are some of the most important objections:
- Responsibility: singer makes no distinction between people who are responsible for the child (or the poor) and those who aren't. Have the citizens of all countries the same moral obligation to contribute?
- Burden sharing: what if the others are not helping or contributing? Are you still supposed to bear burden?
- Distance: Singer makes no mention to distance. People tend to care more about those close to them than about distant anonymous people they have never encounter ("out of sight, out of mind")
- Duties to those "near and dear": some argue that you should prioritize alleviating harm to those that are closer to you. Should people be concerned about the global poor or first try to solve the problem in their own town or country?
- Freedom to act: Singer's reasoning makes people to pursue always the general good rather than their own interests and projects.
- Charitable organizations' administrative costs are very high. A big share of the money given for charity does not reach the poor but is spent in salaries, trips, promotion and marketing.
- Is charity hypocritical? Some argue that charity is an "easy good" that gives us peace of mind but does not help changing the systemic problems that cause inequality and poverty. From this point of view in the long run charity could even be detrimental to global good.
- Charity may produce harm: There are also problems of poor coordination among donors, accusations of resources diverted to corrupt officers, doubts about the positive economic effects of foreign aid in local markets.
Do you agree with Peter Singer? Is helping the poor a moral obligation? Is charity necessary and good? Why? Vote and share your views on this important political, ethical and philosophical issue on the discussion forum below.
Recommended readings:
- Salomon, M. (2011) "Why should it matter that others have more? Poverty, Inequality, and the potential of international human rights law", Review of International Studies 37(5), pp. 2137-2155 (article)
- Singer, P (1972) 'Famine, Affluence, and Morality", Philosophy and Public Affairs 1(2), pp. 229-243 (article)
- Wenar, L. (2010) "Poverty is No Pond": Challenges for the Affluent", in Giving Well: The Ethics of Philanthropy, Illingworth, P., T. Pogge and L. Wenar (eds) Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Further resources:
- Test yourself and find out how rich you are compared to the rest of the world population (click here)
Watch these very interesting videos with the contrasting views of two great contemporary philosophers: Peter Singer and Slavoj Žižek.
If you change your mind, you can change your vote simply by clicking on another option.
New to netivist?
Join with confidence, netivist is completely advertisement free. You will not receive any promotional materials from third parties.
Join the debate
In order to join the debate you must be logged in.
Already have an account on netivist? Just login. New to netivist? Create your account for free.
85 xp
78 posts
45 xp
44 posts
This is an incredible relief, I can’t believe this, all the anxiety is gone, I’m credit card dept free with an excellent 804 credit score, all thanks to Mr. Jerry. Looking back, I was very stubborn and didn’t realize how much I needed help but I’m very grateful I took a leap of faith with jerrylinkcreditgroup At G mail dot com, they fixed everything, now I feel more financially competent as well as the weight of dept and high interest rates have been lifted off my shoulders, Cheers to them for a good job.
32 xp
37 posts
I'm delighted to share how I successfully overcame the Herpes virus using natural medication {HERBS}. Through a native local medicine prepared by Doctor Awase, I managed to suppress the virus and improve my overall well-being at the first week. Two weeks into taking the medication, I became fine totally and no more single outbreak/symptoms. Today, I'm living a fulfilling and Herpes-free life.![cured] Confirmed by my Doctor after going for a medical checkup. I am herpes free. Demonstrating that natural approaches can offer effective solutions for health challenges such as herpes. He also cures HPV, PCOS, Fibroid, Endometriosis and lots more. See how to reach out below.
WhatsApp +2349074997110
Email:- dr.awaseherbalhome@gmail. com
32 xp
37 posts
I'm delighted to share how I successfully overcame the Herpes virus using natural medication {HERBS}. Through a native local medicine prepared by Doctor Awase, I managed to suppress the virus and improve my overall well-being at the first week. Two weeks into taking the medication, I became fine totally and no more single outbreak/symptoms. Today, I'm living a fulfilling and Herpes-free life.![cured] Confirmed by my Doctor after going for a medical checkup. I am herpes free. Demonstrating that natural approaches can offer effective solutions for health challenges such as herpes. He also cures HPV, PCOS, Fibroid, Endometriosis and lots more. See how to reach out below.
WhatsApp +2349074997110
Email:- dr.awaseherbalhome@gmail. com
32 xp
37 posts
I'm delighted to share how I successfully overcame the Herpes virus using natural medication {HERBS}. Through a native local medicine prepared by Doctor Awase, I managed to suppress the virus and improve my overall well-being at the first week. Two weeks into taking the medication, I became fine totally and no more single outbreak/symptoms. Today, I'm living a fulfilling and Herpes-free life.![cured] Confirmed by my Doctor after going for a medical checkup. I am herpes free. Demonstrating that natural approaches can offer effective solutions for health challenges such as herpes. He also cures HPV, PCOS, Fibroid, Endometriosis and lots more. See how to reach out below.
WhatsApp +2349074997110
Email:- dr.awaseherbalhome@gmail. com
32 xp
37 posts
I'm delighted to share how I successfully overcame the Herpes virus using natural medication {HERBS}. Through a native local medicine prepared by Doctor Awase, I managed to suppress the virus and improve my overall well-being at the first week. Two weeks into taking the medication, I became fine totally and no more single outbreak/symptoms. Today, I'm living a fulfilling and Herpes-free life.![cured] Confirmed by my Doctor after going for a medical checkup. I am herpes free. Demonstrating that natural approaches can offer effective solutions for health challenges such as herpes. He also cures HPV, PCOS, Fibroid, Endometriosis and lots more. See how to reach out below.
WhatsApp +2349074997110
Email:- dr.awaseherbalhome@gmail. com
32 xp
37 posts
I'm delighted to share how I successfully overcame the Herpes virus using natural medication {HERBS}. Through a native local medicine prepared by Doctor Awase, I managed to suppress the virus and improve my overall well-being at the first week. Two weeks into taking the medication, I became fine totally and no more single outbreak/symptoms. Today, I'm living a fulfilling and Herpes-free life.![cured] Confirmed by my Doctor after going for a medical checkup. I am herpes free. Demonstrating that natural approaches can offer effective solutions for health challenges such as herpes. He also cures HPV, PCOS, Fibroid, Endometriosis and lots more. See how to reach out below.
WhatsApp +2349074997110
Email:- dr.awaseherbalhome@gmail. com
32 xp
37 posts
I'm delighted to share how I successfully overcame the Herpes virus using natural medication {HERBS}. Through a native local medicine prepared by Doctor Awase, I managed to suppress the virus and improve my overall well-being at the first week. Two weeks into taking the medication, I became fine totally and no more single outbreak/symptoms. Today, I'm living a fulfilling and Herpes-free life.![cured] Confirmed by my Doctor after going for a medical checkup. I am herpes free. Demonstrating that natural approaches can offer effective solutions for health challenges such as herpes. He also cures HPV, PCOS, Fibroid, Endometriosis and lots more. See how to reach out below.
WhatsApp +2349074997110
Email:- dr.awaseherbalhome@gmail. com
123 xp
114 posts
4 xp
4 posts
I invested in a cryptocurrency platform online and i was duped, i was devastated about being duped but coming across premiumhackservices@gmail.com changed the whole story and turned it around and all my investment was recovered, reaching them on Whatsapp +14106350697 can be easier, now i invested in a company recommended to me by them and now i am receiving the expected returns.
123 xp
114 posts
248 xp
244 posts
I am writing this testimonial with immense gratitude and a renewed sense of hope in my heart. For years, I battled with the physical and emotional torment caused by the herpes virus. It felt like an unending struggle, until I discovered a remarkable solution that changed my life forever. Like many others, I had tried countless remedies, medications in search of a cure. I had lost hope, resigned to the belief that herpes was something I would have to live with indefinitely. However, fate intervened and led me to a breakthrough that altered the course of my life. Upon stumbling on a revolutionary treatment option, my skepticism slowly transformed into a flicker of hope. The treatment was a natural remedy from Dr Awase [ HERBS ] Over time, as I followed… Read more
248 xp
244 posts
I am writing this testimonial with immense gratitude and a renewed sense of hope in my heart. For years, I battled with the physical and emotional torment caused by the herpes virus. It felt like an unending struggle, until I discovered a remarkable solution that changed my life forever. Like many others, I had tried countless remedies, medications in search of a cure. I had lost hope, resigned to the belief that herpes was something I would have to live with indefinitely. However, fate intervened and led me to a breakthrough that altered the course of my life. Upon stumbling on a revolutionary treatment option, my skepticism slowly transformed into a flicker of hope. The treatment was a natural remedy from Dr Awase [ HERBS ] Over time, as I followed… Read more
248 xp
244 posts
I am writing this testimonial with immense gratitude and a renewed sense of hope in my heart. For years, I battled with the physical and emotional torment caused by the herpes virus. It felt like an unending struggle, until I discovered a remarkable solution that changed my life forever. Like many others, I had tried countless remedies, medications in search of a cure. I had lost hope, resigned to the belief that herpes was something I would have to live with indefinitely. However, fate intervened and led me to a breakthrough that altered the course of my life. Upon stumbling on a revolutionary treatment option, my skepticism slowly transformed into a flicker of hope. The treatment was a natural remedy from Dr Awase [ HERBS ] Over time, as I followed… Read more
248 xp
244 posts
I am writing this testimonial with immense gratitude and a renewed sense of hope in my heart. For years, I battled with the physical and emotional torment caused by the herpes virus. It felt like an unending struggle, until I discovered a remarkable solution that changed my life forever. Like many others, I had tried countless remedies, medications in search of a cure. I had lost hope, resigned to the belief that herpes was something I would have to live with indefinitely. However, fate intervened and led me to a breakthrough that altered the course of my life. Upon stumbling on a revolutionary treatment option, my skepticism slowly transformed into a flicker of hope. The treatment was a natural remedy from Dr Awase [ HERBS ] Over time, as I followed… Read more
248 xp
244 posts
I am writing this testimonial with immense gratitude and a renewed sense of hope in my heart. For years, I battled with the physical and emotional torment caused by the herpes virus. It felt like an unending struggle, until I discovered a remarkable solution that changed my life forever. Like many others, I had tried countless remedies, medications in search of a cure. I had lost hope, resigned to the belief that herpes was something I would have to live with indefinitely. However, fate intervened and led me to a breakthrough that altered the course of my life. Upon stumbling on a revolutionary treatment option, my skepticism slowly transformed into a flicker of hope. The treatment was a natural remedy from Dr Awase [ HERBS ] Over time, as I followed… Read more
1991 xp
782 posts
Here are my recommendations. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT is the best choice to recover your lost funds back. I fell victim to a fake online crypto broker with my investment of $958,000. The broker promised me significant profits and I was initially successful in trading, which built trust with the broker. I have never been so inconsolable in my life, having given them my utmost trust only to be fooled in this manner. While looking for help after losing my investment funds. I came across numerous endorsements and testimonials about THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of r… Read more
1991 xp
782 posts
Here are my recommendations. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT is the best choice to recover your lost funds back. I fell victim to a fake online crypto broker with my investment of $958,000. The broker promised me significant profits and I was initially successful in trading, which built trust with the broker. I have never been so inconsolable in my life, having given them my utmost trust only to be fooled in this manner. While looking for help after losing my investment funds. I came across numerous endorsements and testimonials about THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of r… Read more
123 xp
114 posts
248 xp
244 posts
I am writing this testimonial with immense gratitude and a renewed sense of hope in my heart. For years, I battled with the physical and emotional torment caused by the herpes virus. It felt like an unending struggle, until I discovered a remarkable solution that changed my life forever. Like many others, I had tried countless remedies, medications in search of a cure. I had lost hope, resigned to the belief that herpes was something I would have to live with indefinitely. However, fate intervened and led me to a breakthrough that altered the course of my life. Upon stumbling on a revolutionary treatment option, my skepticism slowly transformed into a flicker of hope. The treatment was a natural remedy from Dr Awase [ HERBS ] Over time, as I followed… Read more
248 xp
244 posts
I am writing this testimonial with immense gratitude and a renewed sense of hope in my heart. For years, I battled with the physical and emotional torment caused by the herpes virus. It felt like an unending struggle, until I discovered a remarkable solution that changed my life forever. Like many others, I had tried countless remedies, medications in search of a cure. I had lost hope, resigned to the belief that herpes was something I would have to live with indefinitely. However, fate intervened and led me to a breakthrough that altered the course of my life. Upon stumbling on a revolutionary treatment option, my skepticism slowly transformed into a flicker of hope. The treatment was a natural remedy from Dr Awase [ HERBS ] Over time, as I followed… Read more
248 xp
244 posts
I am writing this testimonial with immense gratitude and a renewed sense of hope in my heart. For years, I battled with the physical and emotional torment caused by the herpes virus. It felt like an unending struggle, until I discovered a remarkable solution that changed my life forever. Like many others, I had tried countless remedies, medications in search of a cure. I had lost hope, resigned to the belief that herpes was something I would have to live with indefinitely. However, fate intervened and led me to a breakthrough that altered the course of my life. Upon stumbling on a revolutionary treatment option, my skepticism slowly transformed into a flicker of hope. The treatment was a natural remedy from Dr Awase [ HERBS ] Over time, as I followed… Read more
47 xp
45 posts
I was diagnosed of herpes in 2019 and I tried all possible means to get cure but all to no avail until i saw a post in a health forum about a herbal doctor from Africa who prepare herbal medicine to cure all kind of diseases including herpes virus, at first i doubted if it was real but decided to give it a try, when i contact this herbal doctor via his email i bought the herpes herbal medicine and received it through DHL within 7 days and used it as prescribed, i tested negative to herpes virus within 3 weeks of usage. Thanks to Dr Ughulu His email: drughulupowerfulspelltemple@gmail.com And Calling Number: +1(252) 409-1841 More Reviews on his site: https://drughulupowerfulsp.wixsite.com/my-site-ughulu WHATSAPP NUMBER: +1(720) 794-2516
1 xp
1 posts
I want to say a very big thank you to you spyexpert0@gmail.com, this hacker gave me what I have been looking for, for over 5 years. I have always wanted to have my spouse phone hacked with no trace and spyexpert0@gmail.com made it possible.
32 xp
37 posts
Hello! I’m very excited to share what worked for me to everyone. I’m completely cured from my HSV1&2 with the use of natural medicine. I have used Oregano oil, Coconut oil, Acyclovir, Valacyclovir, Famciclovir and some other products/supplements and it hasn’t helped ever since I was diagnosed. I got outbreaks frequently and was completely devastated and I went online for a possible cure and how to get rid of Herpes. On a fateful day after taking my bath, I took my phone and was going through some research, I bumped into a testimonial of a Herbs doctor { Dr Awase } who cures diverse diseases/viruses with Herbal medication. I was hopeful but also doubted the claim. But after a while I thought “what do I have to lose?” so I decided to re… Read more
32 xp
37 posts
I'm delighted to share how I successfully overcame the Herpes virus using natural medication {HERBS}. Through a native local medicine prepared by Doctor Awase, I managed to suppress the virus and improve my overall well-being at the first week. Two weeks into taking the medication, I became fine totally and no more single outbreak/symptoms. Today, I'm living a fulfilling and Herpes-free life.![cured] Confirmed by my Doctor after going for a medical checkup. I am herpes free. Demonstrating that natural approaches can offer effective solutions for health challenges such as herpes. He also cures HPV, PCOS, Endometriosis and lots more. See how to reach out below.WhatsApp +2349074997110Email:- dr.awaseherbalhome@gmail. com
32 xp
37 posts
I'm delighted to share how I successfully overcame the Herpes virus using natural medication {HERBS}. Through a native local medicine prepared by Doctor Awase, I managed to suppress the virus and improve my overall well-being at the first week. Two weeks into taking the medication, I became fine totally and no more single outbreak/symptoms. Today, I'm living a fulfilling and Herpes-free life.![cured] Confirmed by my Doctor after going for a medical checkup. I am herpes free. Demonstrating that natural approaches can offer effective solutions for health challenges such as herpes. He also cures HPV, PCOS, Endometriosis and lots more. See how to reach out below.WhatsApp +2349074997110Email:- dr.awaseherbalhome@gmail. com
68 xp
63 posts
1 xp
1 posts
I just got my cheating husband iPhone 16 hacked by verifiedprohackers@gmail.com and it really worked with no trace.
3419 xp
4418 posts
Hello everyone, my name is Kiara Hahn from California. I want to share my story about a powerful spell caster named Dr. Jakuta. I was heartbroken when my fiancé left me without warning, and I spent the last month feeling confused, guilty, and devastated. Desperate for help, I searched online for relationship advice and found Dr. Jakuta, who has helped many people with their relationship problems. I reached out to him, and he promised to bring my fiancé back to me within 72 hours. After following his instructions, my fiancé surprisingly showed up at my doorstep, apologized, and now we're living happily together again. If you're having relationship issues, you can contact Dr. Jakuta at:
Email: doctorja… Read more
Join the debate
In order to join the debate you must be logged in.
Already have an account on netivist? Just login. New to netivist? Create your account for free.
