In order to provide you with a better experience, netivist uses a limited amount of cookies. Learn more about the way we use them by reading our Cookies Policy. By continuing to browse netivist you are agreeing to our policy.

What do you think of the restrictions in Magic tournaments on the use of cards from older editions?



magic the gathering rules

Source: Composite by G_marius based on an Oliver Hallmann´s image

The restrictions imposed on the use of some cards in Magic: the Gathering tournaments are controversial. What do you think about these restrictions?

Magic: the Gathering is a trading card game created by Richard Garfield and marketed by Wizards of the Coast in 1993. This highly successful card game has had already 16 editions and more than 50 expansion sets. However the DCI, the official body for competitive play imposes restrictions on the cards that can be used in most tournaments. Usually only the latest editions and expansions are allowed in tournaments. This rule introduces dynamism in competition because players need to constantly update their card games and strategies, but also frustration because previous investments in cards become obsolete.

 

 

What do you think about these restrictions?  Vote and share your views with us!


Vote to see result and collect 1 XP. Your vote is anonymous.
If you change your mind, you can change your vote simply by clicking on another option.





Join the debate

In order to join the debate you must be logged in.



Already have an account on netivist? Just login. New to netivist? Create your account for free.





...
Lvl 1
5 xp

4 posts
#18  |  Samantha Jeggins  26 November 2024 @ 08:53
"I decided to try out the services of software Specialist, he helps people to recover lost funds. I can vouch for him because I have used him when I lost a considerable amount of money in a dubious online investment. To be honest, I was skeptical at first but to my surprise he was able to recover my lost funds within a few weeks. The guy was professional and efficient in his work and what I liked most about him is that he kept updating me on the process of recovering my lost funds. Till today all I do is appreciate his generosity and that is why I decided to give this information to the public of how good he renders his services. Contact him on his mail on ETHICALHACKERS009@GMAIL.COM OR CALL OR TEXT ‪@ethicalhackers23 for great hacking services. Contact them for any kind of hack at all a… Read more
...
Lvl 3
113 xp

53 posts
#17  |  Jay Russell  22 November 2024 @ 14:21
HARNESS THE EFFECIENCY OF CRYPTO RECOVERY-SYNACK TECH
I came across SYNACK TECH which is an exceptional and highly reputable private licensed investigation firm based in the states that i had the privilege of engaging with after my company suffered a loss of $950,000 worth of btc due to a mistaken transfer to an unknown account by our financial accountant. Despite our desperate attempts to recover the funds through traditional channels and various recovery firms, we were met with disappointment and further financial losses. However, our fortunes changed when we discovered SYNACK TECH. Upon contacting them, their team of skilled professionals' swiftly and effectively managed to recover $830,300 of our lost funds, bringing immense relief and peace to our company. Their dedication and e… Read more
...
Lvl 6
582 xp

286 posts
#16  |  Dana Crandel  27 October 2024 @ 22:54
SYNACK TECH IS FAST AND EFFECIENT
You really need to be careful of the risk involved in the world of cryptocurrency and investments. I was naive enough to believe I could make huge returns from my cryptocurrency investments without doing proper research about it. I lost $543,000 worth of USDT and BTC in a failed cryptocurrency investment scheme. Luckily for me, I was able to reach out to a reputable cryptocurrency recovery company that goes by the name Synack Tech and was able to successfully recover all the money I had invested into the scheme. {{{s y n a c k h a c k @ t e c h | - | c e n t e r | d o t | c o m }}} I'm forever grateful to the services of Synack Tech and this message is a recommendation to everyone who intends to recover lost digital assets of any kind. Not only are t… Read more
...
Lvl 7
983 xp

448 posts
#15  |  Jordy Wattss  11 October 2024 @ 09:38
SYNACK HACKERS IS RESTORING ALL LOST DATA,ASSETS AND PEACE OF MIND
I was once a victim of a heart-wrenching cryptocurrency scam that left me devastated. I had invested a significant sum of $95,000 worth of Ethereum in an online investment platform, hoping to reap substantial profits. Little did I know that I was about to face a nightmare. As the weeks went by, my excitement turned into despair when I realized that the platform I had trusted was nothing more than an elaborate scheme to rob unsuspecting investors like me my hard-earned Ethereum, leaving me feeling helpless and betrayed. After extensive research, I came across Synack Hackers Recovery Team, a crypto recovery specialist who helps victims like me regain their stolen assets. After weeks of tireless efforts, s y n a c k h a … Read more
...
Lvl 2
28 xp

27 posts
#14  |  Richard Corbin44  09 September 2024 @ 06:08
WIZARD SCHWARTZ CRYPTO RECOVERY

"I cannot thank Schwartz Software Hackers Program enough for helping me recover my money from a crypto scam. I was devastated when I realized I had fallen victim to a fraudulent investment Website, but thanks to Schwartz Software Hackers services, I was able to get my hard-earned money back. Their group of experienced experts put forth a lot of effort to work on my case and they successfully traced and recovered my lost funds. Without the help of Schwartz Software Hackers Program, I don't know where I would be today. I appreciate Schwartz Software Hackers Program for offering this crucial and worthwhile service." https://t.me/schwartzsoftwarehackers

Contact Information;
Email:Schwartzsoftwarehackingprogram@gmail.com
chat th… Read more
...
Lvl 5
265 xp

234 posts
#13  |  helen cosmos  24 August 2023 @ 23:27

I had lost so much money in cryptocurrency until i met Mighty Hacker Yuri.
Hi, My name is Helen Cosmos. it was 6 months ago these all started, i saw an advert to invest in cryptocurrency by one EXPRESS CRYPTO INVESTMENT. I did infact invest up to $530,647.88 only to find out it was a ponzi scheme! I became depressed but just 2 days ago i met with Mighty Hacker Yuri and i received all my lost cryptocurrency back and even was taught how to defend myself against such cyber predators. Thank You Mighty Hacker Yuri.
mightyyuri @ consultant . com
+1,828,630,8408 (WhatsAp)
mightyyuri9.wixsite.com/mighty-hacker-yuri

...
Lvl 2
29 xp

29 posts
#12  |  Layla Cole  30 August 2022 @ 12:10
Special thanks to HACK VANISH, a professional hacker I’ve been hiring for the past 2 years because, I find him to be an outstanding hacker who has aided me in various hacking-related issues, ranging from fixing my poor FICO credit score of about 437 TransUnion, 462 Equifax to 802 plus excellent score, tracking my cheating husband’s phone and currently has helped me recover my lost crypto funds from an online scam investment I recently ventured into, I must confess he is the best, quite brilliant, ever since I discovered him through a positive review I saw on Wallet Hub and reached out to him via Email: HACKVANISH @ GMAIL. COM, and Phone: +1(747) 293-8514, to which he responded in less than 10mins, I have never regretted working with him, he’s been quite helpful and highly efficient. I Wou… Read more
...
Lvl 6
554 xp

449 posts
#11  |  Betty Kari  28 September 2021 @ 19:46
I am very pleased with the help CYBER CREDIT GURU rendered in restoring my credits. I am a disabled Veteran who over the past 2 years had to let my credit go due to health priorities that were not covered by VA & other insurance, my credit scores were 514 Experian, 515 Equifax, and 518 TransUnion. No public records, only 3 open Accts but several collection Accts with Zero Balances, few Weeks ago, I ran into some Credit blogs on the net which led me to CYBER CREDIT GURU the most talked about US based Russian hacker, who tremendously repaired and upgraded my credit score to 784, 789, and 802 within the 3 Bureaus in just a Week after I contacted him. If faced with similar challenge, connect with him via: C Y B E R C R E D I T G U R U (AT) G M A I L (DOT) C O M or Call / Text: +1(650) 239 724… Read more
...
Lvl 2
39 xp

5 posts
#10  |  matthew myers  11 March 2015 @ 22:50

It depends on the format you play! A new player is going to have a hard time collecting the right cards to build a good modern deck. In Which is current cards and cards that go back 10 years.standard format is the only thaT requires cards from the past 2 years (soon to be 18 months). This is better for newer players as new cards are easier to obtain. As their collection grows however, players can trade into older cards to play in other formats, or pay for them when they feel ready. The DCI doesn't restrict older cards from play. If you want to play a deck with older cards, play modern or legacy.

...
Lvl 1
12 xp

1 posts
#9  |  Mark Stoddard  24 December 2014 @ 21:44
So, when I first saw this I thought it meant using the same card from an older edition and requiring players to have the new printings. But in seeing this, whoever posted this doesn't know much about magic. If we were to abolish the ban-list and have all cards ever printed legal. It would be detrimental to the game for several reasons. 1. The only format would be vintage. Competitive vintage decks cost thousands of dollars. Noone would start playing because noone wants to spend that much on a hobby they are starting out on. 2. Game Play would suffer. There would be about a billion ways to get a turn 1 kill with no ban list and with all cards ever printed legal. 8-9 turn standard games would be pretty rare. 3. If this did happen wizards would have to make more powerful cards so th… Read more
...
Lvl 4
168 xp

32 posts
#8  |  Francisco Sánchez García  04 November 2014 @ 08:00    Avenger  (#7)

If anyone has bought a power 9 card without knowing that it cant't be played in other competitive formats except vintage, at least can play it casual and there were a legion of players willing to play against him, I would be one of them. Of course it also can be sold later surely with a better price. I don't think that nowadays someone buy a black lotus without knowing it.

...
Lvl 9
2528 xp

516 posts
#7  |  Avenger  03 November 2014 @ 13:32    Francisco Sánchez García  (#5)

Thanks! It's true another reason is somehow to keep the value of users investments. Although this policy can harmed investors as well. What about those gamers that bought the famous Black Lotus by a fortune and then found out that they could not use it anymore in most tournaments?

...
Lvl 4
168 xp

32 posts
#6  |  Francisco Sánchez García  02 November 2014 @ 12:42
If a magic player want to play in a format that permits almost all of the cards that have been printed, he/she have to make a vintage deck, but has to spend several thousands of dollars/euros/pounds to achieve that in order to have a deck that can win games. The existence of several formats of play in fact benefits the game itself, because you can see different mechanics that wouldn't be seen if the only format allowed were vintage. In fact that format is curious, those decks are extremely fast and the games last only a few turns if not only one. People would get bored from Magic fast if the games would last only one of two turns. If all games only last one turn, Magic would dissapear.

The most popular format nowadays is "modern", it permits cards that have been published in th… Read more
...
Lvl 4
168 xp

32 posts
#5  |  Francisco Sánchez García  02 November 2014 @ 12:14    Avenger  (#4)
The thing is more complex than simply ban cards from a format. If there were only one format to play, it would be like today's vintage format, that only has a list of restricted cards, you can have 4 cards with the same name in your deck normally and only 1 of a card of that list. Those cards have proven an enormous power for the game itself and if wizards would permit 4 of them in the decks, the vintage format would be broken, every copy of a card in that list would cost thousands of dollars and people would abandon magic because only a few people would buy one of these cards and have real possibilities to win championships. For example, the most iconic card of the game, black lotus, on internet can be buyed for at least 1500 euros now, and you don't need more than one because you can't … Read more
...
Lvl 9
2528 xp

516 posts
#4  |  Avenger  28 October 2014 @ 10:17    Francisco Sánchez García  (#3)

I understand that banning some cards is a way to limit the chances of some decks that show to be superior to others. However I think they could avoid that same effect by simply including a simple rule that brings some more randomness to the game. Like that you can use whatever cards you want in the game but that at the beginning of each play both players may discard (without looking at them 10 cards from their decks). That could make no deck unbeatable and could allow you keep on playing with all cards.

...
Lvl 4
168 xp

32 posts
#3  |  Francisco Sánchez García  06 October 2014 @ 20:15

In Magic the Gathering there are various formats and sanctioned tournaments. The truth is that there are a very few cards that cannot see game in none of the formats there are, mostly the ones that changes the "ante" during a game, because the ante was removed from the game long ago.

...
Lvl 6
661 xp

82 posts
#2  |  ronalcubo  16 September 2014 @ 12:08

I was a Magic player in the past, and already at the time the DCI started imposing restrictions. Of course there is the business reason for that. There is also another question... with so many different cards, the possible combinations of them were huge and gave rise to unexpected decks. In the past, DCI had to modify their rules according to that several times. An example is the card Land Tax, which was a card that gave rise to many combos.

By restricting to the new entries, DCI already knows all possible estrategies, and all competitive decks come up very soon via internet. There is no more fun in configuring a deck.

...
Lvl 8
1257 xp

247 posts
#1  |  Antoine  01 September 2014 @ 16:23

Also I am not a Magic player I am familiar with the game and my opinion is that it's a business, a very profitable niche business. As long as the players still accept to pay for new cards, why should the company change its strategy? It's true it may be unfair and expensive, so the players with more financial ressources may have more opportunities to win, but life is usually unfair anyway...


Join the debate

In order to join the debate you must be logged in.



Already have an account on netivist? Just login. New to netivist? Create your account for free.


Next Article