Are EU Commissioners independent or loyal to the national interest of their own countries?
We discuss the appointment and independence of EU Commissioners following the Günther Oettinger's controversial remarks. Do you think they prioritize party or national interests? Join our discussion and help improve the way EU institutions work.
Günther Oettinger's controversy
EU institutions are under scrutiny and often criticized for not being fully democratic or for prioritizing some national interests. Independence, separation of powers, accountability and responsiveness are central concerns of EU citizens. A sense of frustration emerges when EU representatives and decision-makers seem to favor the interests of specific Member States or political parties.
There are good reasons to explore the political orientations of commissioners, especially in light of recent events that has unfolded. At the end of October 2016, the Commissioner for Digital Economy and Society, Günther Oettinger, made offensive remarks describing Chinese people as "slitty-eyed" and for having "their hair combined from left to right with shoe polish." These racist remarks were taped during an after-dinner speech addressed to business leaders in Hamburg.
However, his slurs did not end there as he continued to make homophobic comments about German MPs introducing a law for "mandatory gay marriage." These comments come after a new position in the EU Commission has opened up for Oettinger. After the departure of the Budget Commissioner. Kristalina Georgieva, Oettinger is to replace her. Despite his gaffe, Ms Merkel, whose party Mr Oettinger belongs to, continues to stand firmly behind him to support his promotion. The result? The issue was buried and Oettinger received the promotion. Merkel’s intervention is curious especially considering the EU Commissioners’ supposed independence from national politics.
A Primer: How are the European Commissioners elected?
A Commissioner is a member of the 28-member European Commission who are the equivalent of national cabinet ministers. Each member state will nominate a suitable candidate for the post, and it is the Commission President’s discretion to receive these nominations. These nominations are selected from a pool of candidates associated with the governing parties. Oettinger, for example, hails from Merkel’s CDU. The European Parliament will vote on the suitability of the President’s team as a whole. Each member is required to take an oath before the Court of Justice swearing to be “independent in carrying out [their] responsibilities” and not to “seek nor take instructions from any Government”. Constitutionally, European Commissioners are to be independent of their member states. Is this really the case?
Are EU Commissioners independent?
These are some of the most commonly cited arguments for and against independence
Arguments for their independence:
- A legal interpretation:
Commissioners are not to “seek nor take instructions from any government or any other body”. This constitutional independence is formally enshrined in Article 213.2 of the Treaty on European Union (TEU).
- A sociological constructivist interpretation:
Commissioners spend the majority of their time socializing with their directorates general (DGs) who they lead, who head bureaucratic units tasked to aid the Commissioner. Commissioners specialize and develop expertise in policy areas which they are nominated for, rather than meddle in the domestic political arena. This view belongs to that of the constructivist scholars who believe that EU officials, by virtue of their prolonged periods of socialization in Brussels, acquire new views and political preferences.
- EU Commissioners often make collective decisions, that is they adopt agendas through consensus. If a Commissioner resolutely supports member states’ positions, they are unlikely to have much popular support in the commission, nor will agendas be pushed through. This collective decision-making model significantly constraints the abilities of Commissioners to pander to national interests.
Arguments against their independence:
- Member states vet their nominations, preferring commissioners whose political preferences are closer to their domestic politics. Although the Commission President has the authority to halt these nominations, these opposition has rarely been made public. In reality, the President often has to depend on member states’ support for a successful term, hence are unlikely to oppose these nominations.
- Commissioners often depend on national governments for career development after leaving the European Commission. This provide incentives to continue to tow the party line.
In recent debates over reforming or enlarging the European Union, the independence of European Commissioners is an underemphasized issue. We invite you to participate in our debate on the continual ways to improve the European Union and guarantee a truly independent supranational institution over narrow domestic priorities.
Watch this videos one explaining how the European Commision works and the other on Günther Oettinger's gaffes and slurs
If you change your mind, you can change your vote simply by clicking on another option.
New to netivist?
Join with confidence, netivist is completely advertisement free. You will not receive any promotional materials from third parties.
Join the debate
In order to join the debate you must be logged in.
Already have an account on netivist? Just login. New to netivist? Create your account for free.
25 xp
24 posts
41 xp
38 posts
I wanted to purchase a car months ago, but I wasn’t approved for a loan, I needed a score of at least 700 to be approved for the loan, but my score was 519. I had many hard inquiries, collections, late payments, unpaid debts and an eviction. I contacted this life saver PINNACLE CREDIT SPECIALIST. They helped me wipe all the negative items and raised my score to 793. It’s been 2 weeks now and nothing is coming back. Call their number +1(409) 331-2269. Or text them by email: PINNACLESCREDITSPECIALIST@GMAIL.COM
41 xp
39 posts
For years, I struggled with the emotional and physical burden of the herpes virus, believing I would have to live with it forever. I tried countless treatments, medications, and therapies, but nothing seemed to bring lasting relief. It felt like a battle with no end in sight until I discovered a natural remedy that changed everything (herbs). Skeptical at first, I decided to give it a try, and to my surprise, I started noticing improvements in my overall well-being within two days of taking the medication. With consistency as prescribed by the herbal doctor, I felt healthier, more energized, and free from the symptoms that had once controlled my life. After completing the treatment, (14days) I visited my doctor for confirmation, and I was overjoye… Read more
2031 xp
905 posts
The most reputable and trustworthy recovery experts available today. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. They can help you retrieve your stolen crypto funds. They have technical expertise resources to track down and recover lost crypto. I had lost £973,000 to fraud and at first I thought it was gone for good. I went online to search for recovery, I saw numerous testimonies regarding THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT and how they had assisted other people in getting their money back. I didn’t hesitate to contact them, in just a few days the experts returned all my money. They said that they did an investigation and returned my money immediately. They can never ask you for any upfront payment. They … Read more
2031 xp
905 posts
The most reputable and trustworthy recovery experts available today. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. They can help you retrieve your stolen crypto funds. They have technical expertise resources to track down and recover lost crypto. I had lost £973,000 to fraud and at first I thought it was gone for good. I went online to search for recovery, I saw numerous testimonies regarding THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT and how they had assisted other people in getting their money back. I didn’t hesitate to contact them, in just a few days the experts returned all my money. They said that they did an investigation and returned my money immediately. They can never ask you for any upfront payment. They … Read more
2031 xp
905 posts
The most reputable and trustworthy recovery experts available today. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. They can help you retrieve your stolen crypto funds. They have technical expertise resources to track down and recover lost crypto. I had lost £973,000 to fraud and at first I thought it was gone for good. I went online to search for recovery, I saw numerous testimonies regarding THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT and how they had assisted other people in getting their money back. I didn’t hesitate to contact them, in just a few days the experts returned all my money. They said that they did an investigation and returned my money immediately. They can never ask you for any upfront payment. They … Read more
1694 xp
521 posts
Hello guys my name is Cletus Kim. I wanted to share a testimony of how I recovered my lost funds. All thanks to the humble and expert hacker. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. Last month I contacted the EXPERT for help, after I read several reviews about them. I even reached out to one of their clients who had worked with them in the past just to verify how genuine they are before I could proceed. I invested with this fake platform some months ago, first month everything was going well and I got my payout normally as usual until I made a top up on my account and invested over $1.5,000 more and that was when everything was shut out and I couldn’t withdraw anymore and they kept on asking for more money , I almost lost … Read more
1694 xp
521 posts
Hello guys my name is Cletus Kim. I wanted to share a testimony of how I recovered my lost funds. All thanks to the humble and expert hacker. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. Last month I contacted the EXPERT for help, after I read several reviews about them. I even reached out to one of their clients who had worked with them in the past just to verify how genuine they are before I could proceed. I invested with this fake platform some months ago, first month everything was going well and I got my payout normally as usual until I made a top up on my account and invested over $1.5,000 more and that was when everything was shut out and I couldn’t withdraw anymore and they kept on asking for more money , I almost lost … Read more
1694 xp
521 posts
Hello guys my name is Cletus Kim. I wanted to share a testimony of how I recovered my lost funds. All thanks to the humble and expert hacker. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. Last month I contacted the EXPERT for help, after I read several reviews about them. I even reached out to one of their clients who had worked with them in the past just to verify how genuine they are before I could proceed. I invested with this fake platform some months ago, first month everything was going well and I got my payout normally as usual until I made a top up on my account and invested over $1.5,000 more and that was when everything was shut out and I couldn’t withdraw anymore and they kept on asking for more money , I almost lost … Read more
89 xp
85 posts
Haven’t you heard about Schwartz Software Hackers Services the deal in Fund Recovery and Mobile spy and other people had benefited from it? I am KRISTEN STEPHEN by name, I want to share a blog and forums on how to get a real fund recovery firm, thanks to Schwartz Software Hackers who helped me in recovering my funds from a romance scam and I was so poor without funds that I got frustrated. One morning as I was browsing the internet, I saw different comments of people testifying of how Schwartz Software Hackers helped him from being poor to a rich man through this already hacked ATM CARD. I was skeptical if this was true, I decided t… Read more
115 xp
112 posts
I have been suffering from Herpes for the past 1 years and 8 months, and ever since then I have been taking series of treatment but there was no improvement until I came across testimonies of Dr. Silver on how he has been curing different people from different diseases all over the world, then I contacted him as well. After our conversation he sent me the medicine which I took according to his instructions. When I was done taking the herbal medicine I went for a medical checkup and to my greatest surprise I was cured from Herpes. My heart is so filled with joy. If you are suffering from Herpes or any other disease you can contact Dr. Silver today on this Email address: drsilverhealingtemple@gmail.com
41 xp
38 posts
I felt so happy when I emailed PINNACLE CREDIT SPECIALIST to fix my credit profile. Before I emailed him, I had 501 TU, 590 EQ and 582 EX credit scores. I had about $5k in credit card debt, 7 inquiries and some couple of collections which dropped my scores by 20 points almost every week. After I contacted PINNACLE CREDIT SPECIALIST he raised my credit score to an excellent score within a few days. He also paid off the credit card debts and removed the negative items on my credit report. This experience I can never forget. For those who need his Contact Details: PINNACLECREDITSPECIALIST@GMAIL.COM
582 xp
286 posts
You really need to be careful of the risk involved in the world of cryptocurrency and investments. I was naive enough to believe I could make huge returns from my cryptocurrency investments without doing proper research about it. I lost $543,000 worth of USDT and BTC in a failed cryptocurrency investment scheme. Luckily for me, I was able to reach out to a reputable cryptocurrency recovery company that goes by the name Synack Tech and was able to successfully recover all the money I had invested into the scheme. {{{s y n a c k h a c k @ t e c h | - | c e n t e r | d o t | c o m }}} I'm forever grateful to the services of Synack Tech and this message is a recommendation to everyone who intends to recover lost digital assets of any kind. Not only are t… Read more
60 xp
55 posts
I was wondering how possible it is to raise my credit score from 500 to 800. I’ve been looking for some ways to improve my credit score after some financial difficulties. I had 11 late payments reported from Bridgecrest during the pandemic when I was laid off and dealing with some health issues. Unfortunately, I fell behind on my payment during that time, until I came across a PINNACLE CREDIT SPECIALIST who cleaned all the mess on my credit report, marking all late payment as paid on time. I’m a lot happier now because my scores moved from 526 to 801 across the board. Thanks to PINNACLE CREDIT SPECIALIST. Here is the contact to reach out to them: PINNACLECREDITSPECIALIST@GMAIL.COM Or +1 (409) 231-0041.
516 xp
394 posts
I highly recommended GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER to everyone out there to help you get back your stolen funds or BTC. Also there are lots of fraudulent recovery firms out there, so you need to be careful not to end up being defrauded again. I wanted to take a moment to express my utmost gratitude for the help of GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. I had invested over $857,000 USD into a crypto broker that turned out to be a total fraud. It was disheartening and frustrating. I discovered GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. Through the testimony of scam victims, that's how I got to know about this recovery expert. From the moment I… Read more
516 xp
394 posts
I highly recommended GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER to everyone out there to help you get back your stolen funds or BTC. Also there are lots of fraudulent recovery firms out there, so you need to be careful not to end up being defrauded again. I wanted to take a moment to express my utmost gratitude for the help of GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. I had invested over $857,000 USD into a crypto broker that turned out to be a total fraud. It was disheartening and frustrating. I discovered GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. Through the testimony of scam victims, that's how I got to know about this recovery expert. From the moment I… Read more
2000 xp
812 posts
Email: geovcoordinateshacker@gmail.com
WhatsApp +1 (512) 550 1646
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
Please everyone should be careful and stop being deceived by all these online scammers? I lost about $645,000 to these online scammers a few months ago. It took a while before I realized they were scammers and this really hurt me. I had no idea what to do. A friend of mine heard about it and recommended me to a recovery expert called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. After a few hours of work with them, I was shocked to learn that they had recovered all of my stolen cryptocurrency in just 72 hours. I… Read more
2000 xp
812 posts
Email: geovcoordinateshacker@gmail.com
WhatsApp +1 (512) 550 1646
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
Please everyone should be careful and stop being deceived by all these online scammers? I lost about $645,000 to these online scammers a few months ago. It took a while before I realized they were scammers and this really hurt me. I had no idea what to do. A friend of mine heard about it and recommended me to a recovery expert called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. After a few hours of work with them, I was shocked to learn that they had recovered all of my stolen cryptocurrency in just 72 hours. I… Read more
2000 xp
812 posts
Email: geovcoordinateshacker@gmail.com
WhatsApp +1 (512) 550 1646
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
Please everyone should be careful and stop being deceived by all these online scammers? I lost about $645,000 to these online scammers a few months ago. It took a while before I realized they were scammers and this really hurt me. I had no idea what to do. A friend of mine heard about it and recommended me to a recovery expert called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. After a few hours of work with them, I was shocked to learn that they had recovered all of my stolen cryptocurrency in just 72 hours. I… Read more
1917 xp
726 posts
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or eve… Read more
1917 xp
726 posts
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or eve… Read more
1917 xp
726 posts
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or eve… Read more
1917 xp
726 posts
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or eve… Read more
3419 xp
4418 posts
Hello everyone my name is Kiara Hahn from California US. I’m here to testify of a great and powerful spell caster called Dr Jakuta. I was so confused and devastated when my fiance left me without a word, I've spent the last month crying and feeling guilty. I wasn't talking to anybody, so one day I search online on love tips because I needed him back desperately and I loved him so much, until I found Dr Jakuta who has solved so many relationship problems then I contacted him and he promised that in less than 72hrs he will come back to me. After I did all he asked, to my greatest surprise my fiance who had refused to speak with me came to my house and asked for forgiveness for all he had made me g… Read more
2034 xp
842 posts
GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKERS. Are angels sent from heaven? I recently finished working with them. He helped me retrieve my stolen cryptocurrencies which I never thought could be retrieved ever again because I have tried with so many recovery hackers in the past but none of them was able to pull it off just like he did. I never thought it was possible to recover stolen cryptocurrency due to past experiences trying to recover $925,000 that was stolen from my Paxful wallet. Based on my experience, it is not that easy to get back a lost or stolen bitcoin because these scammers are very smart and they will cover their tracks but if you manage to… Read more
2034 xp
842 posts
GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKERS. Are angels sent from heaven? I recently finished working with them. He helped me retrieve my stolen cryptocurrencies which I never thought could be retrieved ever again because I have tried with so many recovery hackers in the past but none of them was able to pull it off just like he did. I never thought it was possible to recover stolen cryptocurrency due to past experiences trying to recover $925,000 that was stolen from my Paxful wallet. Based on my experience, it is not that easy to get back a lost or stolen bitcoin because these scammers are very smart and they will cover their tracks but if you manage to… Read more
2034 xp
842 posts
GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKERS. Are angels sent from heaven? I recently finished working with them. He helped me retrieve my stolen cryptocurrencies which I never thought could be retrieved ever again because I have tried with so many recovery hackers in the past but none of them was able to pull it off just like he did. I never thought it was possible to recover stolen cryptocurrency due to past experiences trying to recover $925,000 that was stolen from my Paxful wallet. Based on my experience, it is not that easy to get back a lost or stolen bitcoin because these scammers are very smart and they will cover their tracks but if you manage to… Read more
2034 xp
842 posts
GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKERS. Are angels sent from heaven? I recently finished working with them. He helped me retrieve my stolen cryptocurrencies which I never thought could be retrieved ever again because I have tried with so many recovery hackers in the past but none of them was able to pull it off just like he did. I never thought it was possible to recover stolen cryptocurrency due to past experiences trying to recover $925,000 that was stolen from my Paxful wallet. Based on my experience, it is not that easy to get back a lost or stolen bitcoin because these scammers are very smart and they will cover their tracks but if you manage to… Read more
2034 xp
842 posts
GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKERS. Are angels sent from heaven? I recently finished working with them. He helped me retrieve my stolen cryptocurrencies which I never thought could be retrieved ever again because I have tried with so many recovery hackers in the past but none of them was able to pull it off just like he did. I never thought it was possible to recover stolen cryptocurrency due to past experiences trying to recover $925,000 that was stolen from my Paxful wallet. Based on my experience, it is not that easy to get back a lost or stolen bitcoin because these scammers are very smart and they will cover their tracks but if you manage to… Read more
2166 xp
863 posts
Do you need help in reclaiming lost Crypto Wallets, retrieving Crypto lost to Scammers. There is only one way to go about it, You should contact GEO COORDINATES HACKER to do all in its power to help you recover it all. A specialized Expert with cyber specialties to recover scammed funds. They work with professionalism and discretion. I was in total dismay when I lost my entire savings investing in cryptocurrency. I came to learn about GEO COORDINATES HACKER through my old friend. I got in touch with the Expert, and after submitting my reports, The Expert was able to recover my funds. I’m truly grateful for their service and I recommend them to everyone who needs to recover their funds. For further information, contact COORDINATES HACKE… Read more
Join the debate
In order to join the debate you must be logged in.
Already have an account on netivist? Just login. New to netivist? Create your account for free.
