Should our government be permitted to legally spy on us? The privacy vs security dilemma
Source: This image was created for netivist.org. If you want to use it you simply need to attribute it by linking to this page or to https://netivist.org. Thanks
Governments legally spying on citizens? We discuss the privacy vs security and freedom vs safety dilemmas, and in particular if government mass surveillance programs are justified. Join our debate in cyber-security and vote in our poll (below)
Debate created by Paul McNeil
Privacy vs security: government surveillance programs
The new wikileaks releases about CIA hacking documents have brought back to the public opinion the trade-offs between privacy and security. We are living in the post-Snowden-revelations era, following the 2014 unveiling of mass surveillance programs, such as the controversial and highly confidential PRISM surveillance system, run by the National Security Agency (NSA) in the United States. That exposure led to extreme public outrage over the government's intrusion into our everyday privacy. Today, however, unprecedented developments have also been witnessed as public opinion has shifted dramatically, with steps taken to actually approve more invasive government surveillance programs.
Did terrorist attacks across Europe plunge us to the depth of self-monitoring? At a time when discussions about online privacy concerns have increased in various nations across the globe, people of democratic countries in the heart of Europe are making their voices heard, and even voting in referendums, to mandate further surveillance of the people by the government. This can be seen as an unanticipated side effect of recent terrorist attacks in Europe and the United States. Many questions are raised over the pros and cons and the moral rights and wrongs over what has been dubbed legal government spying.
History
In response to the horrendous 9/11 terrorist attacks, leaving nearly 3,000 people dead across America, the U.S. led the world not only in the war against terror, but also in taking action to launch measures to increase monitoring methods and techniques on home soil. It is a known fact that one can never take on an initiative against an enemy if they lack any security back home. America, for example, ratified the famous Patriot Act back in 2001 and although the bill enjoyed enormous approval during its adoption, and despite the fact it was renewed by a 280 to 138 vote again by the House of Representatives in March 2006, many of the provisions remain highly controversial to say the least, and many have even faced court challenges. The freedom vs safety dilemma was resolved in favor of the latter. Laws on immigration, banking, money laundering and methods to carry out foreign surveillance were completely overhauled or amended.
Watch this video by the Wall Street Journal on PRISM secret surveillance program
In favor and against government surveillance
Advocates
There are advocates of further government surveillance, arguing the central government of every country should be provided the authority to literally hack into your computers and install malware, all in a legal fashion. Under such cyber-security policy the government should be permitted to tap into internet comms and telephones, and install hidden cameras and various types of “bugs” in all types of public, and private, locations with the ultimate goal of gathering security data. These advocates believe in the primacy of security over privacy.
Again those in favor of such practices by the government voice their side of the debate especially by citing the need to use such systems and advanced technology to target terrorism in this day and age. While mainland America may for now enjoy relative security in the post-September 11 era, nearly all of Europe has been engulfed in fear of terrorism as Paris, Brussels and other large metropolitan cities across the Green Continent have become favored targets for terrorist cells hell-bent on creating havoc and making life miserable for the ordinary European.
As a result, governments are overtly and covertly resorting to such methods of enhanced surveillance in their quest to hunt down and neutralize such cells, and ensure their public that they can provide safety. The irony is that one terrorist cell can enormously impact the political landscape of a European country, and lead to a chain reaction of growing concerns across countries with a collective population of over 800 million.
Governments also emphasize that such surveillance and monitoring technology can be used to counter espionage efforts, hinder the spread of weapons of mass destruction and attacks–through terrorism and cyberattacks such as those with Pegasus spyware–targeting infrastructure considered significantly important on a national scale.
Opponents
Understanding the sensitivity of the matter, some governments may take on the initial stance of limiting the use of such powers to a certain number of intrusions each year. However, what controlling and observation mechanisms will ensure this promise remains uncertain. With the NSA’s PRISM surveillance program setting a very bad example in the public’s mind, there is a huge concern about such Internet mass surveillance systems becoming generalized before we are able to decide whether this is desirable. Opponents also claim intelligence services have no right to spy on every single aspect of ordinary citizen’s lives, as PRISM literally does, and there has to be some kind of respect to our privacy. Are the basic and fundamental rights of citizens violated through the use of preventive surveillance and mass observation? Those who reply yes to such a question are advocates of encryption technology provided by Apple and other companies, and their approach to the privacy of their customers.This may not be simply a problem of national security vs privacy, but other civil rights may also be endangered. A government spying on citizens may instil fear and lose legitimacy.
While many countries have imposed laws authorizing the legal electronic communications interception and data mining, the misuse of such authority by various governments across the planet has made the general public quite wary about backdoors. Governments may be pushing companies to leave covert loopholes in their software, and the public only realizing after it’s already too late. The Yahoo 500 million account hack, with speculations of nearly a billion accounts being involved, has led to further speculations about Washington forcing such companies to scan customer e-mails for the U.S. intelligence community.
The bottom line
The truth is that fears about various threats and support to enhance government mass surveillance powers have increased as terror attacks began targeting mainland Europe. There are the somewhat "centralists" on this topic who believe comprehensive security will only be realized if harmony is achieved between technology and legal protections, involving meaningful tech companies and governments across the globe.
Ideally governments would be able to reach a point of adopting a system of proper checks-and-balances, enshrined in the law, to allow the government to present this entire issue of mass surveillance “for the greater good” of the public all the more palatable. Gaining federal court approval and the consent of ministers before utilizing any powers is one such consideration. Of course, accountability and effectiveness must be properly balanced to ensure that such technology can contribute to security.
Final thoughts
As controversial and heated as this topic has been, and will most definitely continue to be, there is one fctor which has recieved insufficient attention. We as a society must continue to mature in order to comprehend how we can actually discover and reach the right balance between civil rights and national security. The correct ethics in this regard is out there, waiting for us to reach the point of being able to digest its importance, and thus carry out the necessary measures. This may mean allowing the government into some aspects of our lives, while also placing into action the correct system of checks and balances to regulate law enforcement authority and the use of spyware. However challenging the task, we owe it to the next generations, and ourselves, to reach a logical concept to pave the path forward.
Watch this interview with Edward Snowden
If you change your mind, you can change your vote simply by clicking on another option.
New to netivist?
Join with confidence, netivist is completely advertisement free. You will not receive any promotional materials from third parties.
Join the debate
In order to join the debate you must be logged in.
Already have an account on netivist? Just login. New to netivist? Create your account for free.
84 xp
79 posts
Well, nothing to really say, but thanks to PINNACLE CREDIT SPECIALIST, I did it! After having a 620-credit score 11 years ago, car repo etc. I finally settled down with a Pinnacle Credit Specialist who helped me pay all my shit and now my score is 809. It feels good, I still can’t believe Pinnacle Credit Specialist did it for me. Hit them up by email: PINNACLECREDITSPECIALIST@GMAIL.COM / +1 (409) 331-2269.
1673 xp
551 posts
I am out here to spread this good news to the entire world on how THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT and his terams help me in recovering my lost Bitcoin. I never thought I could get scammed of my Bitcoin , I never knew these investments were fake. I was depressed and in anger but all thanks to THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT for the help and professional service offered to me in my time of need. I invested $1.3 million in a cryptocurrency platform and found out it was a scam and I had no idea how to get my money back until I contacted THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT To anyone out there seeking to recover any lost bitcoin from cryptocurrency forms of online scams or wallet hackers , I recommend TH… Read more
1673 xp
551 posts
I am out here to spread this good news to the entire world on how THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT and his terams help me in recovering my lost Bitcoin. I never thought I could get scammed of my Bitcoin , I never knew these investments were fake. I was depressed and in anger but all thanks to THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT for the help and professional service offered to me in my time of need. I invested $1.3 million in a cryptocurrency platform and found out it was a scam and I had no idea how to get my money back until I contacted THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT To anyone out there seeking to recover any lost bitcoin from cryptocurrency forms of online scams or wallet hackers , I recommend TH… Read more
4 xp
4 posts
1 xp
1 posts
Captain WebGenesis possesses a wealth of knowledge in the cryptocurrency space, particularly in identifying scams and recovering lost funds. They walked me through the entire recovery process, outlining the steps we needed to take. Their transparency and commitment to helping me regain my lost investment were evident throughout our interactions. It all started innocently enough. I was excited about the potential of cryptocurrency and eager to invest in a promising new project. Little did I know, the website I stumbled upon was a facade designed to lure unsuspecting investors like me. After a few clicks, my funds were gone, and the realization hit hard: I had been scammed. As I dug deeper into the wor… Read more
1694 xp
521 posts
Hello guys my name is Cletus Kim. I wanted to share a testimony of how I recovered my lost funds. All thanks to the humble and expert hacker. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. Last month I contacted the EXPERT for help, after I read several reviews about them. I even reached out to one of their clients who had worked with them in the past just to verify how genuine they are before I could proceed. I invested with this fake platform some months ago, first month everything was going well and I got my payout normally as usual until I made a top up on my account and invested over $1.5,000 more and that was when everything was shut out and I couldn’t withdraw anymore and they kept on asking for more money , I almost lost … Read more
1694 xp
521 posts
Hello guys my name is Cletus Kim. I wanted to share a testimony of how I recovered my lost funds. All thanks to the humble and expert hacker. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. Last month I contacted the EXPERT for help, after I read several reviews about them. I even reached out to one of their clients who had worked with them in the past just to verify how genuine they are before I could proceed. I invested with this fake platform some months ago, first month everything was going well and I got my payout normally as usual until I made a top up on my account and invested over $1.5,000 more and that was when everything was shut out and I couldn’t withdraw anymore and they kept on asking for more money , I almost lost … Read more
149 xp
143 posts
I highly recommend THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT to anyone who wants to recover lost bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies from online scammers, wallet hackers, or if you ever sent bitcoins to the incorrect wallet address. I invested a total of €700,550 worth of Bitcoin with an online company that specialized in trading. The company had guaranteed me a 25% return per week on my investment. Feeling a mix of frustration and anxiety, I sought out a reliable solution to recover my funds back. I found it very hard to move on. God so kind I followed a broadcast that teaches how scammed victims can recover their funds. That’s when I discovered THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. They are such very good expert… Read more
149 xp
143 posts
I highly recommend THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT to anyone who wants to recover lost bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies from online scammers, wallet hackers, or if you ever sent bitcoins to the incorrect wallet address. I invested a total of €700,550 worth of Bitcoin with an online company that specialized in trading. The company had guaranteed me a 25% return per week on my investment. Feeling a mix of frustration and anxiety, I sought out a reliable solution to recover my funds back. I found it very hard to move on. God so kind I followed a broadcast that teaches how scammed victims can recover their funds. That’s when I discovered THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. They are such very good expert… Read more
9 xp
6 posts
open a case with them on proh4ckz@protonmail/com
Their team used quantum computing to break the encryption and regain control of our systems. But they didn’t stop there. They traced the ransom payment through the blockchain to a dark web cryptocurrency exchange, where they identified the attackers and recovered a significant portion of the funds. Their ability to navigate the deep web and leverage cutting-edge… Read more
10 xp
9 posts
My name is Linda Boris, a real estate investor from North Dakota, I had invested in crypto last year and was hoping to make double my investment by the start of this new year until I realized I was being conned. It was devastating for me and my family, and if not for the intervention of Morphohack Cybersecurity Service, I wouldn’t have recovered my funds.
Morphohack is a top-notch cryptocurrency and data recovery company, that help its clients to retrieve crypto assets from hackers and fake investment brokers, I’m grateful for their service in helping me recover my $600k worth of crypto funds and I highly recommend their services, they can be trusted and are very reliable with a 100% success r… Read more
10 xp
9 posts
My name is Linda Boris, a real estate investor from North Dakota, I had invested in crypto last year and was hoping to make double my investment by the start of this new year until I realized I was being conned. It was devastating for me and my family, and if not for the intervention of Morphohack Cybersecurity Service, I wouldn’t have recovered my funds.
Morphohack is a top-notch cryptocurrency and data recovery company, that help its clients to retrieve crypto assets from hackers and fake investment brokers, I’m grateful for their service in helping me recover my $600k worth of crypto funds and I highly recommend their services, they can be trusted and are very reliable with a 100% success r… Read more
40 xp
55 posts
I cannot express my gratitude enough to Jetwebhackers for their exceptional help in recovering the $65,540 I lost to a deceitful crypto scam. I had invested this money to pay for my husband’s emergency medical treatment when I was approached by a scammer impersonating an agent named David. He promised me an astonishing return of $650,940, but it was nothing more than a trap.
Fortunately, Jetwebhackers stepped in with their expertise and dedication, and not only did they help me reclaim my original investment, but I also received the promised profit. Their support has truly been a lifesaver for my family during this challenging time. We can now concentrate on my husband’s recovery without the burden of financial worri… Read more
40 xp
55 posts
I cannot express my gratitude enough to Jetwebhackers for their exceptional help in recovering the $65,540 I lost to a deceitful crypto scam. I had invested this money to pay for my husband’s emergency medical treatment when I was approached by a scammer impersonating an agent named David. He promised me an astonishing return of $650,940, but it was nothing more than a trap.
Fortunately, Jetwebhackers stepped in with their expertise and dedication, and not only did they help me reclaim my original investment, but I also received the promised profit. Their support has truly been a lifesaver for my family during this challenging time. We can now concentrate on my husband’s recovery without the burden of financial worri… Read more
40 xp
55 posts
I cannot express my gratitude enough to Jetwebhackers for their exceptional help in recovering the $65,540 I lost to a deceitful crypto scam. I had invested this money to pay for my husband’s emergency medical treatment when I was approached by a scammer impersonating an agent named David. He promised me an astonishing return of $650,940, but it was nothing more than a trap.
Fortunately, Jetwebhackers stepped in with their expertise and dedication, and not only did they help me reclaim my original investment, but I also received the promised profit. Their support has truly been a lifesaver for my family during this challenging time. We can now concentrate on my husband’s recovery without the burden of financial worri… Read more
40 xp
55 posts
I cannot express my gratitude enough to Jetwebhackers for their exceptional help in recovering the $65,540 I lost to a deceitful crypto scam. I had invested this money to pay for my husband’s emergency medical treatment when I was approached by a scammer impersonating an agent named David. He promised me an astonishing return of $650,940, but it was nothing more than a trap.
Fortunately, Jetwebhackers stepped in with their expertise and dedication, and not only did they help me reclaim my original investment, but I also received the promised profit. Their support has truly been a lifesaver for my family during this challenging time. We can now concentrate on my husband’s recovery without the burden of financial worri… Read more
803 xp
1004 posts
A GENUINE HACKER FOR HIRE/SPOTLIGHT RECOVERY
Have you lost hope that scammers will ever return your money? The good news is that SPOTLIGHT RECOVERY, a Certified Recovery Expert, can help you get your money back 98% of the time. I gave up on ever making money from binary trading after losing nearly 115,000 euros to a dishonest broker. I spent a lot of time looking for ways to get the money back after the loss. Eventually, I came across SPOTLIGHT, a specialist in bitcoin recovery who helps victims of scams recoup their losses. My case was handled by the expert, and I was paid in full. To anyone looking for a recovery firm to retrieve their lost cryptocurrency. You can contact SPOTLIGHT at spotlightrecovery@protonmail.com.
803 xp
1004 posts
A GENUINE HACKER FOR HIRE/SPOTLIGHT RECOVERY
Have you lost hope that scammers will ever return your money? The good news is that SPOTLIGHT RECOVERY, a Certified Recovery Expert, can help you get your money back 98% of the time. I gave up on ever making money from binary trading after losing nearly 115,000 euros to a dishonest broker. I spent a lot of time looking for ways to get the money back after the loss. Eventually, I came across SPOTLIGHT, a specialist in bitcoin recovery who helps victims of scams recoup their losses. My case was handled by the expert, and I was paid in full. To anyone looking for a recovery firm to retrieve their lost cryptocurrency. You can contact SPOTLIGHT at spotlightrecovery@protonmail.com.
803 xp
1004 posts
A GENUINE HACKER FOR HIRE/SPOTLIGHT RECOVERY
Have you lost hope that scammers will ever return your money? The good news is that SPOTLIGHT RECOVERY, a Certified Recovery Expert, can help you get your money back 98% of the time. I gave up on ever making money from binary trading after losing nearly 115,000 euros to a dishonest broker. I spent a lot of time looking for ways to get the money back after the loss. Eventually, I came across SPOTLIGHT, a specialist in bitcoin recovery who helps victims of scams recoup their losses. My case was handled by the expert, and I was paid in full. To anyone looking for a recovery firm to retrieve their lost cryptocurrency. You can contact SPOTLIGHT at spotlightrecovery@protonmail.com.
9 xp
9 posts
10 xp
10 posts
10 xp
10 posts
10 xp
10 posts
57 xp
52 posts
3 xp
3 posts
29 xp
27 posts
I am Michael. I saw an advertisement discussing how profitable Ethereum and USDT may be when the rate spikes. Since Ethereum has a lot of promise and I have high hopes for the reward that will accompany it, I have put all of my money into it and am waiting for it to develop even more. A few years later, it had produced more profit, and I was prepared to withdraw my money when the problem arose. I became really anxious and had to try every potential solution without success. I stumbled over an article one day while looking around the internet about how Supreme Peregrine Recovery had aided in their recuperation. Digital assets were lost. I muster the bravery to get in touch with them and tell them all that has… Read more
3 xp
3 posts
Have you given up on ever getting your money back from scammers? I have good news for you: a Certified Recovery Expert named RECOVERY NERD can help you recover your money 98% of the time. I lost almost $241,000 to a fraudulent broker, and I gave up on ever turning a profit from binary trading. Following the loss, I spent a lot of time researching ways to get the money back. I eventually found RECOVERY NERD, a specialized cryptocurrency recovery expert that assists scam victims in getting their money back. The expert worked on my case once I submitted it, and I received my money in full. to anyone searching for a recovery company to get their misplaced cryptocurrency back. RECOVERY NERD can be reached via recoverynerd@mail.com
1 xp
1 posts
In the world of cryptocurrency, where mistakes can be costly and recovery options seem limited, FOLKWIN E X P E R T RECOVERY is a true lifesaver. They not only gave me my Bitcoin back but also restored my peace of mind. I can’t express enough how much their expertise, professionalism, and dedication meant to me during one of the most stressful times of my life. If you’re reading this and are in a similar situation, where you’ve lost access to your Bitcoin or other digital assets, do yourself a favor and reach out to FOLKWIN E X P E R T RECOVERY. I had nearly given up hope before I found them, and now I can say with full confidence that they are the real deal. They have the knowledge, t… Read more
3 xp
3 posts
2 xp
2 posts
Join the debate
In order to join the debate you must be logged in.
Already have an account on netivist? Just login. New to netivist? Create your account for free.
