Source: This image was created for netivist.org. If you want to use it you simply need to attribute it by linking to this page or to https://netivist.org. Thanks
We discuss Hong Kong's status within China and the policy of "one country, two systems". Find out more about the history of Hong Kong and whether this Special Administrative Region should be further integrated in China or conversely get more autonomy, or even independence. Vote in our poll and invite others to join.
History of Hong Kong
Hong Kong is currently a Special Administrative Region of the People's Republic of China on the Pearl River Delta. The Chinese Emperor Qin Shi Huang conquered the area of Hong Kong in 214 BC. After the collapse of the Qin Dynasty, it became part of the Kingdom of Nanyue in 204 BC. Later Hong Kong became a possession of the Han dynasty and an international trading center, part of the Bao'an County. In the eighth century Hong Kong became a military stronghold and in the 13th century it was ruled by the Mongols.
In the fourteenth century the Ming dynasty established a maritime prohibition to prevent contact with foreigners. In 1513, the Portuguese explorer Jorge Alvares, arrived in Hong Kong and established a trading post. This was the first, and short, relationship with the West, as the Portuguese merchants were soon expelled by the Chinese government. In the eighteenth century many Hong Kongese were forced to migrate inland by the Manchu Qing dynasty. In 1841 after the First Opium War, the British captured Hong Kong Island. Hong Kong was ceded in perpetuity to the United Kingdome in 1842 under the Treaty of Nanking. British rule was only interrupted by Japanese occupation from 1941 to 1945. In 1997 Britain transferred sovereignty over Hong Kong to the People's Republic of China, marking the end of 156 years of colonial rule.
“The socialist system and policies shall not be practised in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, and the previous capitalist system and way of life shall remain unchanged for 50 years.”
(Chapter 1, Article 5 of the Hong Kong Basic Law)
Ever since, the relationship between Hong Kong and China has always been fraught with tension. When the British handed Hong Kong back to China in 1997 under the aegis of a “One Country, Two Systems” method of governance, it was hoped that the agreement could be preserved to maintain the autonomy of Hong Kong, at least until the 2047 expiry date of the agreement. As such, Hong Kong is formally designated as a Special Administrative Region, with significant political autonomy, and is not wholly integrated with China. Yet in recent years the high-handedness with which the Chinese central government has handled political affairs in Hong Kong increasingly has been seen to betray the fundamental tenets of autonomy enshrined in the original agreement.
The Umbrella Revolution
The issue of independence did not enter the mainstream psyche of the local population until a hugely successful mass demonstrations was staged in Hong Kong’s CBD area late 2014. The Umbrella Revolution—as it was dubbed—was triggered as a result of new legislative proposals to amend electoral laws to the detriment of democratic procedures. At its peak, participants numbered 100,000 and brought business to a complete standstill in occupied areas. Although no formal political concessions were made at the end of the mass unrest, there is a palpable sense—especially amongst once political apathetic youths—that the status quo of “One Country, Two Systems” is really a disguise for increasing restrictions of civil autonomy in Hong Kong. The oppositional movements were galvanized, and confidence in public authority plummeted in the aftermath.
The Book Publishing Saga
Despite the de jure independence of Hong Kong’s judicial system, the constriction of civic space in Hong Kong is obvious. The most bizarre case was the abduction of several independent book publishers by Beijing officials. A few were lured across the borders to Hong Kong’s neighbouring city—ShenZhen—before being arrested while another was taken away while in Thailand, in disregard of formal extradiction processes. These independent publishers have frequently sold books banned in China, to the ire of Beijing authorities. Unsurprisingly, several politically sensitive books were pulled off the shelves across independent book stores in the city-state.
Disbarment of the Radical Democratic Legislators
After the 2016 LegCo (Legislative Council) elections, two separatists young legislators were sworn in. During an investiture ceremony, they uttered obscenities that were deemed offensive to China. In intervening against these young radical democrats and expelling them from the legislature, Beijing set a precedent in which future legislators have to swear their loyalty to China.
Watch the video about the incident between Hong Kong nationalists and pro-Beijing supporters
Should Hong Kong be independent from China?
These are some of the most commonly used reasons for and against Hong Kong independence.
In favor of Hong Kong reaching further autonomy or independence:
- Hong Kong has always been an important financial centre in the Asia Pacific region. Disregard for the rule of law by Beijing authorities could mean that business activities could diminish in the future.
- Public opinion polls indicates that about one-sixth of the population favours independence after 2047.
- Hong Kong and Mainland Chinese identity have diverged during the time of British occupation. Increasing assertive Hong Kong nationalism could mean that clashes in the future will only become more heated.
- Hong Kong adopted Western liberal political and economic principles. China's approach to governance, economic planning and media censorship could become a permanent source of frustration.
Against Hong Kong's independence:
- Independence would be meaningless because Hong Kong continues to be extremely dependent on China. It imports as much as 80% of its water sources from China, as well as large amount of electricity and food. As a city-state, an independent Hong Kong is simply unviable.
- China is a fast growing international power, some predict it will replace the USA as the world's hegemon. It can be in the interest of Hong Kong to be a fully integrated part of such a powerful country.
- It has never had its own defence forces. When the British withdrew, so did its forces charged with defending the crown colony. Currently, the People’s Liberation Army maintains a garrison in Hong Kong.
- In recent years, political and economic integration has only accelerated between China and Hong Kong, making these changes extremely difficult to reverse. Independence is costly in economic and political terms.
Watch this video on the differences between Hong Kong and Mainland China:
If you change your mind, you can change your vote simply by clicking on another option.
New to netivist?
Join with confidence, netivist is completely advertisement free. You will not receive any promotional materials from third parties.
Join the debate
In order to join the debate you must be logged in.
Already have an account on netivist? Just login. New to netivist? Create your account for free.
Here are my recommendations. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT is the best choice to recover your lost funds back. I fell victim to a fake online crypto broker with my investment of $958,000. The broker promised me significant profits and I was initially successful in trading, which built trust with the broker. I have never been so inconsolable in my life, having given them my utmost trust only to be fooled in this manner. While looking for help after losing my investment funds. I came across numerous endorsements and testimonials about THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of r… Read more
Here are my recommendations. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT is the best choice to recover your lost funds back. I fell victim to a fake online crypto broker with my investment of $958,000. The broker promised me significant profits and I was initially successful in trading, which built trust with the broker. I have never been so inconsolable in my life, having given them my utmost trust only to be fooled in this manner. While looking for help after losing my investment funds. I came across numerous endorsements and testimonials about THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of r… Read more
Here are my recommendations. THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT is the best choice to recover your lost funds back. I fell victim to a fake online crypto broker with my investment of $958,000. The broker promised me significant profits and I was initially successful in trading, which built trust with the broker. I have never been so inconsolable in my life, having given them my utmost trust only to be fooled in this manner. While looking for help after losing my investment funds. I came across numerous endorsements and testimonials about THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of r… Read more
I need the world to know how THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD recovered my stolen cryptocurrency. It is truly unfathomable how individuals who deceive others out of their hard-earned money can sleep peacefully at night. My personal encounter with these scammers was not only outrageous but also had a severe negative impact on my mental health. I invested a total of $1.8 million. I wanted to take my life because I had nothing else to live for anymore. A friend of mine introduced me to THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD, a renowned cybersecurity and cryptocurrency recovery expert. THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD assured me that I will get all my funds back and guess what? I got it all back. I am grateful that I … Read more
I need the world to know how THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD recovered my stolen cryptocurrency. It is truly unfathomable how individuals who deceive others out of their hard-earned money can sleep peacefully at night. My personal encounter with these scammers was not only outrageous but also had a severe negative impact on my mental health. I invested a total of $1.8 million. I wanted to take my life because I had nothing else to live for anymore. A friend of mine introduced me to THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD, a renowned cybersecurity and cryptocurrency recovery expert. THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD assured me that I will get all my funds back and guess what? I got it all back. I am grateful that I … Read more
I need the world to know how THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD recovered my stolen cryptocurrency. It is truly unfathomable how individuals who deceive others out of their hard-earned money can sleep peacefully at night. My personal encounter with these scammers was not only outrageous but also had a severe negative impact on my mental health. I invested a total of $1.8 million. I wanted to take my life because I had nothing else to live for anymore. A friend of mine introduced me to THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD, a renowned cybersecurity and cryptocurrency recovery expert. THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD assured me that I will get all my funds back and guess what? I got it all back. I am grateful that I … Read more
I need the world to know how THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD recovered my stolen cryptocurrency. It is truly unfathomable how individuals who deceive others out of their hard-earned money can sleep peacefully at night. My personal encounter with these scammers was not only outrageous but also had a severe negative impact on my mental health. I invested a total of $1.8 million. I wanted to take my life because I had nothing else to live for anymore. A friend of mine introduced me to THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD, a renowned cybersecurity and cryptocurrency recovery expert. THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD assured me that I will get all my funds back and guess what? I got it all back. I am grateful that I … Read more
I need the world to know how THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD recovered my stolen cryptocurrency. It is truly unfathomable how individuals who deceive others out of their hard-earned money can sleep peacefully at night. My personal encounter with these scammers was not only outrageous but also had a severe negative impact on my mental health. I invested a total of $1.8 million. I wanted to take my life because I had nothing else to live for anymore. A friend of mine introduced me to THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD, a renowned cybersecurity and cryptocurrency recovery expert. THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD assured me that I will get all my funds back and guess what? I got it all back. I am grateful that I … Read more
I need the world to know how THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD recovered my stolen cryptocurrency. It is truly unfathomable how individuals who deceive others out of their hard-earned money can sleep peacefully at night. My personal encounter with these scammers was not only outrageous but also had a severe negative impact on my mental health. I invested a total of $1.8 million. I wanted to take my life because I had nothing else to live for anymore. A friend of mine introduced me to THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD, a renowned cybersecurity and cryptocurrency recovery expert. THE HACK ANGEL RECOVERY WIZARD assured me that I will get all my funds back and guess what? I got it all back. I am grateful that I … Read more
I simply want to share my story about THE HACKANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. To all of you out there. One has to be careful. A lot of scammers are out there taking money from innocent traders. I was a victim of these crypto scammers. They made me lose my hard earned funds. The best thing that happened to me this year was seeing an article about THE HACKANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. A professional hacker and private investigator. I invested $954,300 in a cryptocurrency platform and it turned out to be a scam and I had no idea how to get my money back until I reached out to a recovery company called THE HACKANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. I explained my situation to them. I was shocked to hear that th… Read more
I simply want to share my story about THE HACKANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. To all of you out there. One has to be careful. A lot of scammers are out there taking money from innocent traders. I was a victim of these crypto scammers. They made me lose my hard earned funds. The best thing that happened to me this year was seeing an article about THE HACKANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. A professional hacker and private investigator. I invested $954,300 in a cryptocurrency platform and it turned out to be a scam and I had no idea how to get my money back until I reached out to a recovery company called THE HACKANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. I explained my situation to them. I was shocked to hear that th… Read more
Hello, everyone here. I am here to give a testimonial on how I met one of the best Hackers so far in my incredible moment of pain. I was taken advantage of by a fake cryptocurrency investment company pretending to help people double their investments. I lost a huge amount of money to a fake investment company. I invested 108,000 USD in this investment company with the belief that I will have a huge return when it was time for me to get my return. The company no longer picks my calls or replies to my email. I was so devastated. I was told Bitcoin is impossible to trace once you lose it but after coming across a post about GEO COORDINATES … Read more
Hello, everyone here. I am here to give a testimonial on how I met one of the best Hackers so far in my incredible moment of pain. I was taken advantage of by a fake cryptocurrency investment company pretending to help people double their investments. I lost a huge amount of money to a fake investment company. I invested 108,000 USD in this investment company with the belief that I will have a huge return when it was time for me to get my return. The company no longer picks my calls or replies to my email. I was so devastated. I was told Bitcoin is impossible to trace once you lose it but after coming across a post about GEO COORDINATES … Read more
reach out to JETWEBHACKERS, on their
EMAIL:jetwebhackers@gmail.com<… Read more
I want to use this Medium to say big thanks to GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER for helping me recover my stolen crypto worth ($745,000) through their hacking skills. I’ve always valued trust and reliability. Unfortunately, that trust was shattered when I fell victim to a cryptocurrency scam who ultimately disappeared, leaving me devastated and feeling hopeless. After investing in a platform that promised high returns and easy access to funds, I found myself unable to withdraw my money for months. I have heard a lot of testimonies about this hacker called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER and I wondered if they could actually help. However, after some thought, I de… Read more
I want to use this Medium to say big thanks to GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER for helping me recover my stolen crypto worth ($745,000) through their hacking skills. I’ve always valued trust and reliability. Unfortunately, that trust was shattered when I fell victim to a cryptocurrency scam who ultimately disappeared, leaving me devastated and feeling hopeless. After investing in a platform that promised high returns and easy access to funds, I found myself unable to withdraw my money for months. I have heard a lot of testimonies about this hacker called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER and I wondered if they could actually help. However, after some thought, I de… Read more
I want to use this Medium to say big thanks to GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER for helping me recover my stolen crypto worth ($745,000) through their hacking skills. I’ve always valued trust and reliability. Unfortunately, that trust was shattered when I fell victim to a cryptocurrency scam who ultimately disappeared, leaving me devastated and feeling hopeless. After investing in a platform that promised high returns and easy access to funds, I found myself unable to withdraw my money for months. I have heard a lot of testimonies about this hacker called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER and I wondered if they could actually help. However, after some thought, I de… Read more
did for me with their magnificent hacking skills, they didn’t just get back my scammed money i invested with a fake investment company that was almost $810.000 but to my greatest surprised I got back the money I invested but they also use their sophisticated skills to get even more than the money I invested that was found in the scam wallet during the period of recovery the transfer all the funds back to my wallet which was even more than I expected. If you have been wondering and looking for a way to get back your scammed funds of any kind, I will suggest you quickly get in contact with… Read more
did for me with their magnificent hacking skills, they didn’t just get back my scammed money i invested with a fake investment company that was almost $810.000 but to my greatest surprised I got back the money I invested but they also use their sophisticated skills to get even more than the money I invested that was found in the scam wallet during the period of recovery the transfer all the funds back to my wallet which was even more than I expected. If you have been wondering and looking for a way to get back your scammed funds of any kind, I will suggest you quickly get in contact with… Read more
You really need to be careful of the risk involved in the world of cryptocurrency and investments. I was naive enough to believe I could make huge returns from my cryptocurrency investments without doing proper research about it. I lost $543,000 worth of USDT and BTC in a failed cryptocurrency investment scheme. Luckily for me, I was able to reach out to a reputable cryptocurrency recovery company that goes by the name Synack Tech and was able to successfully recover all the money I had invested into the scheme. {{{s y n a c k h a c k @ t e c h | - | c e n t e r | d o t | c o m }}} I'm forever grateful to the services of Synack Tech and this message is a recommendation to everyone who intends to recover lost digital assets of any kind. Not only are t… Read more
I just got my money back. I can't even begin to describe how happy I am right now. I used a Bitcoin Bonus to invest $770,000 last month. At first, everything was going smoothly until I attempted to withdraw money from my wallet. I was shocked to see how quickly my profit was increasing each day. I just intended to use the funds and earnings to purchase a new vehicle for Christmas. Last month, (wizardlarry@mail.com) saved my life. I read reports about how he provided business loans and assisted customers in getting their money back. I was able to retrieve all of the money I had lost from those con artists.I have to admit that I heartily endorse this company. The way to contact them is by
wizardlarry@ma… Read more
I just got my money back. I can't even begin to describe how happy I am right now. I used a Bitcoin Bonus to invest $770,000 last month. At first, everything was going smoothly until I attempted to withdraw money from my wallet. I was shocked to see how quickly my profit was increasing each day. I just intended to use the funds and earnings to purchase a new vehicle for Christmas. Last month, (wizardlarry@mail.com) saved my life. I read reports about how he provided business loans and assisted customers in getting their money back. I was able to retrieve all of the money I had lost from those con artists.I have to admit that I heartily endorse this company. The way to contact them is by
wizardlarry@ma… Read more
I just got my money back. I can't even begin to describe how happy I am right now. I used a Bitcoin Bonus to invest $770,000 last month. At first, everything was going smoothly until I attempted to withdraw money from my wallet. I was shocked to see how quickly my profit was increasing each day. I just intended to use the funds and earnings to purchase a new vehicle for Christmas. Last month, (wizardlarry@mail.com) saved my life. I read reports about how he provided business loans and assisted customers in getting their money back. I was able to retrieve all of the money I had lost from those con artists.I have to admit that I heartily endorse this company. The way to contact them is by
wizardlarry@ma… Read more
I’m here to bring you good news about GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. My experience with these scammers came as a great shock to me. As someone who works in finance, I never thought I’d fall for a crypto mining scam. When I immediately lost my $516,000 worth of Crypto to a fraudulent investment platform, I began looking for a genuine crypto recovery agent who could assist me retrieve my lost crypto. I searched the web to find legitimate and genuine assets recovery personnel. After several searches I found GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. I immediately contacted them and submitted all the transaction data. I have hired their services quite a number of times. They do all sorts of ha… Read more
I’m here to bring you good news about GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. My experience with these scammers came as a great shock to me. As someone who works in finance, I never thought I’d fall for a crypto mining scam. When I immediately lost my $516,000 worth of Crypto to a fraudulent investment platform, I began looking for a genuine crypto recovery agent who could assist me retrieve my lost crypto. I searched the web to find legitimate and genuine assets recovery personnel. After several searches I found GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. I immediately contacted them and submitted all the transaction data. I have hired their services quite a number of times. They do all sorts of ha… Read more
I’m here to bring you good news about GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. My experience with these scammers came as a great shock to me. As someone who works in finance, I never thought I’d fall for a crypto mining scam. When I immediately lost my $516,000 worth of Crypto to a fraudulent investment platform, I began looking for a genuine crypto recovery agent who could assist me retrieve my lost crypto. I searched the web to find legitimate and genuine assets recovery personnel. After several searches I found GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. I immediately contacted them and submitted all the transaction data. I have hired their services quite a number of times. They do all sorts of ha… Read more
I was once a victim of a heart-wrenching cryptocurrency scam that left me devastated. I had invested a significant sum of $95,000 worth of Ethereum in an online investment platform, hoping to reap substantial profits. Little did I know that I was about to face a nightmare. As the weeks went by, my excitement turned into despair when I realized that the platform I had trusted was nothing more than an elaborate scheme to rob unsuspecting investors like me my hard-earned Ethereum, leaving me feeling helpless and betrayed. After extensive research, I came across Synack Hackers Recovery Team, a crypto recovery specialist who helps victims like me regain their stolen assets. After weeks of tireless efforts, (s y n a c k h a… Read more
I was wondering how possible it is to raise my credit score from 500 to 800. I’ve been looking for some ways to improve my credit score after some financial difficulties. I had 11 late payments reported from Bridgecrest during the pandemic when I was laid off and dealing with some health issues. Unfortunately, I fell behind on my payment during that time, until I came across a PINNACLE CREDIT SPECIALIST who cleaned all the mess on my credit report, marking all late payment as paid on time. I’m a lot happier now because my scores moved from 526 to 801 across the board. Thanks to PINNACLE CREDIT SPECIALIST. Here is the contact to reach out to them: PINNACLECREDITSPECIALIST@GMAIL.COM Or +1 (409) 231-0041.
Join the debate
In order to join the debate you must be logged in.
Already have an account on netivist? Just login. New to netivist? Create your account for free.